CAPETracker.com

CAPE Ratios

The CAPE Ratio, or Cyclically Adjusted Price-to-Earnings Ratio, is a stock market valuation metric developed by economist Robert Shiller. It is designed to evaluate whether a stock market is overvalued or undervalued by comparing its current price to the average earnings over the past 10 years, adjusted for inflation. This long-term perspective helps smooth out short-term fluctuations in earnings, providing a more stable and reliable measure of market valuation.

How It Works

The CAPE Ratio is calculated as:

CAPE Ratio = Current Stock Price / Average Inflation-Adjusted Earnings (Past 10 Years)

This formula helps account for economic cycles, such as recessions or booms, that can temporarily distort earnings. By using a 10-year average, the CAPE Ratio provides a clearer view of a company’s or market’s long-term earning power.

Historical Context and Purpose

Robert Shiller and John Campbell popularized the CAPE Ratio in the 1980s. They wanted a tool to assess long-term stock market performance and potential risks. Shiller later used this ratio to warn about the dot-com bubble in the late 1990s and the housing market bubble in the mid-2000s. The CAPE Ratio gained attention because of its predictive power regarding long-term stock returns, although it is not reliable for short-term market timing.

Interpreting the CAPE Ratio

  • High CAPE Ratio: Indicates that stock prices are high relative to historical earnings, suggesting potential overvaluation. This could lead to lower long-term returns or even market corrections.
  • Low CAPE Ratio: Suggests undervaluation, meaning stock prices are low compared to earnings, which could indicate higher future returns.

Historically, the U.S. stock market’s average CAPE Ratio has been around 16-17. However, during market bubbles, it has reached extreme highs. For example, before the 1929 crash, it exceeded 30, and during the dot-com bubble, it surpassed 40. Conversely, during the financial crisis of 2008-2009, it dropped to around 15, signaling undervaluation.

Global Perspective on CAPE Ratios

CAPE Ratios vary by region due to economic conditions, growth prospects, and risk factors:

  • U.S. Market: Often has a higher CAPE Ratio due to strong corporate earnings, investor confidence, and a robust economy.
  • European Markets: Typically show lower CAPE Ratios due to slower economic growth and political uncertainties.
  • Emerging Markets: Generally have the lowest CAPE Ratios, reflecting higher volatility and perceived risks but potentially greater growth opportunities.

Limitations of the CAPE Ratio

  1. Not for Short-Term Predictions: The CAPE Ratio is better at forecasting long-term returns (10-20 years) and is not reliable for short-term market timing.
  2. Accounting Changes: Corporate accounting standards have evolved, affecting earnings calculations and potentially distorting historical comparisons.
  3. Interest Rates Impact: Low-interest rates can justify higher CAPE Ratios, as investors are willing to pay more for stocks with low bond yields as an alternative.
  4. Sector Composition Changes: The composition of stock indices changes over time, influencing the CAPE Ratio. For example, the rise of tech companies with high valuations impacts the overall market CAPE Ratio.

Practical Uses for Investors

  • Long-Term Investment Decisions: Investors use the CAPE Ratio to assess market valuation and adjust their asset allocation accordingly. For example, a high CAPE Ratio may prompt a more conservative strategy, while a low CAPE Ratio could indicate buying opportunities.
  • Comparing Markets: Investors compare CAPE Ratios across countries or regions to identify undervalued markets with growth potential.
  • Historical Benchmarks: Comparing current CAPE Ratios with historical averages helps investors gauge relative valuation and potential risks.

Conclusion

The CAPE Ratio is a valuable tool for long-term investors, offering insights into market valuation and helping to manage risk and return expectations. While it has limitations and should not be used in isolation, it remains a powerful metric for understanding stock market dynamics and guiding strategic investment decisions.