CAPETracker.com

CAPE Indices

CAPE Indices refer to stock market indices that are evaluated or constructed using the Cyclically Adjusted Price-to-Earnings (CAPE) ratio. These indices are designed to provide investors with an understanding of how the market is valued relative to its long-term earnings. The CAPE ratio, as mentioned earlier, is the ratio of the current stock price to the average inflation-adjusted earnings over the past 10 years, helping to smooth out short-term volatility and cyclical fluctuations.

Key Concepts Around CAPE Indices:

  1. CAPE as a Valuation Tool: The CAPE ratio is commonly used to assess whether a stock market is overvalued or undervalued, offering a long-term perspective on potential returns. CAPE Indices apply this ratio to compare different markets or sectors based on valuation.
  2. CAPE Index Construction: CAPE indices are typically built by applying the CAPE ratio to the constituent stocks within an index, which can be regional (e.g., U.S., European, or Emerging Markets), or sectoral (e.g., technology, finance, etc.). These indices can track the overall market, or they may be focused on a specific industry or country, giving investors a measure of relative valuation.
  3. Popular CAPE Indices:
    • Shiller’s U.S. Market CAPE: The U.S. market CAPE, often based on the S&P 500 index, is the most widely recognized application of the CAPE ratio. Robert Shiller, who developed the ratio, also tracks and publishes the U.S. market’s CAPE through the Yale University website.
    • Global CAPE Indices: Some funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) use a global CAPE index, which can track the valuation of stock markets around the world using the same methodology.
    • Sector-Specific CAPE Indices: Indices can also be created for specific sectors, such as technology or healthcare, using the CAPE ratio to measure whether those sectors are overvalued or undervalued relative to historical earnings.
  4. Role in Investment Strategy:
    • Valuation Insights: Investors use CAPE indices to make more informed decisions about which regions or sectors are offering favorable valuations based on long-term historical trends.
    • Risk Management: A high CAPE ratio in an index may suggest that the market or sector is overvalued, which could imply greater risk of a correction or lower future returns. Conversely, a low CAPE ratio may signal an undervalued market with potential for growth.
  5. Challenges of CAPE Indices:
    • Changing Market Conditions: The CAPE ratio assumes that historical earnings growth patterns will continue. However, this might not always hold true, especially in rapidly changing economies or industries.
    • Accounting Adjustments: Changes in accounting standards over time can affect the consistency of the earnings data used in calculating CAPE ratios, making long-term comparisons more complex.
    • Interest Rates and Monetary Policy: Low interest rates often justify higher CAPE ratios as they make stocks more attractive compared to bonds. As a result, investors must also consider broader economic and monetary factors when using CAPE indices.
  6. CAPE Indices and ETF/ETP Products: Some Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) and Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs) are designed to track CAPE-based strategies. These financial products may focus on stocks with low CAPE ratios (value investing) or avoid stocks with high CAPE ratios to reduce the risk of overvaluation.

Conclusion:

CAPE Indices are powerful tools for investors who want to assess market valuations over the long term. By providing a historical, inflation-adjusted view of earnings, these indices offer a more comprehensive understanding of market price levels compared to short-term metrics. However, like all financial tools, they should be used in conjunction with other analysis techniques to develop a well-rounded investment strategy.